Weed and Feed Follies
June 30th, 2005 · by Jim Hole
First Published 6/30/2005
Weed and Feed Follies
Over the years, I’ve dealt with many frantic gardening couples. One of the most common scenarios involves one half of the couple pointing the finger at the other about the misapplication of a chemical in the yard. When the right chemical goes in the wrong place, the consequences for your plants can be catastrophic.
Deadly Dinner
Weed and Feed, a popular gardening product marketed under several different brand names, can be quite useful when properly applied, but its name has caused some confusion. As a result, more than one gardener has thought, “Wow, the perfect product – not only will it feed my flowers, it’ll kill the weeds, too!” If only it were that simple.
Weed and Feed is a fertilizer combined with a herbicide such as 2, 4-D; it’s meant to be used only on lawns. Lawns – and grasses in general – have a different metabolism than broad-leaved plants such as annuals, perennials, trees and shrubs. 2, 4-D is a selective herbicide: that is, it will kill broadleaf weeds like dandelions and thistle while leaving grasses (and, unfortunately, the weed quackgrass fits into this category) unscathed. As the weed killer does its work, the fertilizer feeds the grass, encouraging vigorous growth.
But while the herbicide in Weed and Feed discriminates between grasses and broadleaf plants, it can’t discriminate between broadleaf weeds and broadleaf ornamentals, fruits and vegetables. When Weed and Feed is used in flowerbeds, virtually every plant – weeds, flowers, vegetables and all – will be either destroyed or, at the very least, severely damaged.
Once Weed and Feed is spread into a flowerbed, the damage to the flowers shows up very quickly. Bedding plants such as alyssum or marigolds and vegetables such as potatoes and tomatoes are extremely sensitive to 2, 4-D and will soon suffer severe injury. On a warm day, with the plants’ metabolism and growth rate accelerated, the 2, 4-D will be absorbed and plant injury sustained within hours.
Geraniums, salvia and many trees and shrubs aren’t quite as sensitive to low concentrations of 2, 4-D, but if you were to apply even a moderate rate of the herbicide to the foliage of these plants, you can expect rather severe damage.
Symptoms of 2, 4-D damage are always worst at the growing points of affected plants, because the herbicide is absorbed by the leaves and translocated (transported) through the plant’s vascular system to these growing points. Cupping and twisting of the new growth is often diagnostic of a misapplication of this herbicide. Eventually, if they received a high enough dose, the plants will wither and die.
The Only Cure
Unfortunately, little can be done to save plants that have been accidentally exposed to 2, 4-D. Applying water to the soil to wash away the herbicide, which might seem the logical solution at first glance is ineffective; in fact, if anything the water may speed up absorption of the herbicide into its stems and leaves.
The only real solution is time. 2, 4-D won’t harm the soil in the long term; in fact, there are several soil microorganisms that treat 2, 4-D as just another food source. Over the summer, provided the concentration of herbicide isn’t too high, these microorganisms will break the herbicide down completely into its component elements: carbon, nitrogen and chlorine. This may take three or four months, depending on soil composition, moisture and temperature, but once the herbicide has broken down, it’s safe to replant.
Read Before You Feed
Most of the misapplications of Weed and Feed that I’ve come across arise simply because the right product is used for the wrong purpose. And to be honest, it infuriates me that people’s gardens are ruined because a salesperson didn’t have the proper training to make the correct recommendation. I don’t fault these salespeople as much as I fault the companies that retail the product, who often fail to provide anything beyond the most rudimentary training.
Of course, part of the blame must be assigned to gardeners who fail to read the label before applying garden products. But then again, how many of us can honestly say that we’ve thoroughly read any set of instructions, whether they’re for the car, the fridge or the DVD player? Education – even in the form of something as simple as a label – can be the key to avoiding catastrophes large and small.