Farmed Christmas trees
December 28th, 2007 · by Jim Hole
first published December 20, 2007
I have this theory that Smokey the Bear is to blame for our angst about buying real Christmas trees. If you think this sounds personal, you’re right. It all started back in Grade 6. I remember sitting in the gym at my elementary school in St. Albert, watching a reel-to-reel film of a stern-looking Smokey pointing directly at me and saying, “Only you can prevent wildfires.” Gulp! Well, that vision stuck in my mind just about as firmly as the film stuck and melted in that old projector. But even with the presentation cut short, Smokey succeeded in convincing me to question my dad about whether it was a good idea to cut down a tree each year for Christmas.
Now, I know that good old Smokey’s message was really about burned-down rather than cut-down trees, but I still can’t drive by a Christmas tree lot without hearing that bear’s stentorian voice in my head. Fortunately, once the fog of nostalgia clears, common sense prevails and I remember the fact that Christmas trees are farmed no differently than any other commercial crop.
The decision regarding what crop a farmer chooses to grow is based on the same sound principles common to any other business practice. That means deciding to farm cabbages or Christmas trees depends on factors such as climate suitability, cost of production, equipment required, return on investment, not to mention a little something called intuition. But regardless of whether the numbers tell you to plant cabbage or Christmas trees, both crops start their lives as seeds, grow in the ground, absorb sunlight, water and nutrients and, ultimately, are harvested and sold. The resources required to grow cabbage are not a whole lot different than those needed to produce a crop of Christmas trees, either. The only major difference between a crop of trees and a crop of cabbage is that trees take years to grow, whereas cabbage is ready the first season. Of course, there’s also the fact that you can’t eat trees…but neither could you decorate a cabbage plant…or at least not tastefully.
Then what is it that makes us squeamish about harvesting farmed Christmas trees? Well, I think it comes down to the fact that the crops we eat are less scrutinized because we all need food. However, as reasonable an argument as that is, it’s equally easy to argue that food crops leave a greater environmental footprint in the waste department. Here’s why. When it comes to cabbage, I suppose people could be thought of as ‘first-stage, living composters’ because we process food within our bodies, and then it eventually finds its way to waste treatment plants. But besides that not being an image that belongs embossed on a Christmas card, it’s also a process that requires a lot of chemical intervention to turn the waste into a product that can be re-utilized. In contrast, farmed Christmas trees are recycled easily by putting them through the chipper and using them as mulching material around tree and shrub beds. Mulch decomposes in the soil, nourishing other plants, and the cycle is complete. Heck, I’ve even heard a representative from the David Suzuki foundation endorse the use of real Christmas trees.
Of course, I haven’t done a complete environmental audit on cabbage versus Christmas trees, and there are lots of other considerations, but I think you get the picture: trees are farmed like any other crop. As I said in last week’s column, I own an artificial tree because not only is it one of many items that my wife brought along with her into our marriage, I would rather lug a pre-decorated fake up from the basement than strap a real one to the hood of my car. And as silly a deciding factor as that may seem, it’s actually as valid as any other when deciding what you support as a consumer. With that said, however, in a battle between Smokey and Suzuki, I’m still betting that Smokey would win claws down.







If you’re looking for something unique, you’re not alone. Bonsai are quickly becoming a favourite indoor plant. For best results, water plants faithfully and provide them with a bright, indirect light source.