Does Phosphorus Go Green
February 29th, 2008 · by Jim Hole
First published February 21, 2008
Is the grass really greener on the other side of the fence? Well, this year the more appropriate question to ask might be, “Is the grass greener on the other side of provincial borders?”

Why the riddle, you ask? Simple. Beginning in 2009, Manitoba’s government will limit the concentration of phosphorus (technically phosphate) in lawn fertilizers to a maximum of one per cent as a way to reduce the amount of phosphorus that makes its way from lawns and into lakes and rivers. Like all issues regarding pollution, this one is also complicated, but the main concern is that adding phosphorus to our water can lead to an explosion of algae growth. In “normal” phosphorus-starved water, algae are very low. But add extra phosphorus and that algae population skyrockets—the dire results being a wake of oxygen-starved, murky-green water and a whole lot of dead fish.
So now that you are feeling a little uneasy about applying fertilizer to your lawn, it might be a good time to explain a bit more about this mysterious plant nutrient we call phosphorus.
Phosphorus is one of only three elements (along with nitrogen and potassium) that is referred to as a major plant nutrient. Translation: all three are required by plants in fairly large quantities, which is exactly why fertilizer labels lists three hyphenated numbers, with phosphorus always occupying the middle spot on the nutrient list. The main role of this all-important nutrient is to act as the energy currency or fuel that drives plant growth. Plants that are severely deficient in phosphorus are invariably stunted and will often reflect their deficiency by displaying a purplish hue in their foliage. I have seen an entire field of corn (unfortunately, mine) that was stunted and purple for that very reason.
Getting back to lawns, the main controversy regarding phosphorus is not about whether it is essential for growing grass (that’s a no-brainer); it’s about deciding how much is needed and what type is best to use. Manitoba, for example, has many soils that are inherently high in phosphorus, so applying phosphorus to lawns is completely unnecessary.
Saskatchewan and Alberta, however, have a little bit different situations. Because many of our soils show some level of phosphorus deficiency, most of our lawns benefit from the addition of phosphorus-containing fertilizers. Having said that, I have to add that I’ve seen many soil tests from people’s lawns that showed exceptionally high phosphorus levels due to years of high-phosphorus fertilizer applications. Exactly. So what can we do to ensure we’re making good decisions? Well, start by becoming smart, responsible consumers.
A simple rule to remember when buying lawn fertilizer is to only choose those with labels that have a phosphorus number that’s in the single digits. Fertilizers such as16-20-0 (which are often sold as lawn fertilizers), contain a disproportionately high concentration of phosphorus and should never be applied to lawns. The next thing to remember is that the best way to keep phosphorus from ending up in lakes and rivers is to read instructions. Misapplication and over-application are surefire ways to spread phosphorus granules across sidewalks and driveways. Not only won’t your lawn benefit from that, the environment and your wallet won’t either. Across the international border, it’s interesting to note that Minnesota allows the use of phosphorus only for establishing new lawns—any other use requires a certified soil test to prove that the soil is phosphorus deficient.
Intelligent use of phosphorus-containing fertilizers really is the key to keeping our lawns and water bodies in good shape. Phosphorus, after all, is a good thing. But like all things in life, moderation is the key. With it, there’s no reason why we can’t have grass that’s green on both sides of the fence and water that’s blue.






